What Great Leaders Do When Nobody Is Watching

Woman leader resting head on table, showing the private side of authentic leadership

By Nettie Owens, CPO-CD · The Sappari Group

Originally explored on Wake Up Women Leaders — Episode 30

You walk off stage. The lights go down. The confident, outgoing person that the room just watched isn’t the same person who wants to sit alone with a book right now. That gap between the two versions of you has a name.

In Episode 30 of Wake Up Women Leaders, Victoria Whitfield and I talked about authentic leadership and what happens when the way you show up publicly doesn’t match who you actually are behind the scenes.

In the previous blog, we built a 90-day plan. This week we look at whether the leadership identity you’re executing that plan through is truly yours.

The Leadership Gap

“Women leaders will have one face when they’re in front of the clients, the crowd, the camera, or on stage and leading the team,” Victoria said. “And then behind the scenes there’s a whole other version. The gap between the two starts to create this sense of anxiety or inauthenticity.”

I walked through an example of what this looks like in practice: a woman who is an expert, whose programs are full, who commands a room and gets called charismatic and compelling. “This same woman, not because she doesn’t feel like she’s a great leader, but perhaps because how she’s showing up as a leader does not necessarily fit her own personality and style, comes off of stage, the lights are down, and she’s not that outgoing, gregarious person. She’d really prefer just having either one-on-one conversations or no conversation at all.”

That mismatch is the target of authentic leadership practice. Not fixing a flaw but closing the gap between two versions of the same person.

Imposter Syndrome: The Wrong Diagnosis

Victoria drew a distinction worth considering: we aren’t trying to describe imposter syndrome.

“There’s the experience of imposter syndrome, where you are awesome, you are brilliant, and you are putting yourself out there and you’re just ashamed to be seen as brilliant. That’s usually what most people talk about,” Victoria said. “What we’re talking about is that you have created a career, a life, a role that feels successful yet inauthentic to you.”

She also named where that pattern comes from. “For most women, we are socialized and taught to just swallow that. Be grateful for the success, fall in line, fit into the mold of what success should look like.” Authentic leadership means rejecting that mold on purpose, not apologizing for having your own.

“It’s harder because you got to do some personal archaeology,” Victoria said. “But it’s more sustainable long term to do that dig. Who am I? What are my best practices? What are my needs, my values, my hard lines and boundaries? What are my energy levels and cycles?”

Who is the Borrowed Version of You?

One source of the borrowed leadership identity that often gets missed is books.

“Most leadership books are written by men, so we don’t find as many examples of women leaders talking about how they’re showing up as a woman leader,” I said. “You’re going to read pages about this man’s lived experience and go, “this is not mine.””

The fix isn’t to reject every example wholesale. It’s a filter. “Does that feel like me? If I were to use that, if I were to wear that, does that feel like me? Does that help me feel my best as a leader?” That question is how you build your own leadership standards instead of inheriting someone else’s.

I used my own small example: some leadership advice says to make your bed every morning. “As a bed maker, I kind of love this leadership standard, but maybe it’s not yours. I can recall a good friend saying, “I love the look of a disheveled bed.”” Neither version is wrong. The whole point of authentic leadership is simply to pick the one that’s actually yours.

“If we keep following those examples over time, we’re going to create a bigger and bigger gap,” I said. “The anxiety will grow, the tendency towards addiction, burnout, all of that will grow.”

Tools for Self-Leadership

Victoria connected authentic leadership to a tool that she has built her practice around. “Strategic meditation is a tool for taking inspired and aligned action. It is essentially a self-leadership tool,” she said. “It is how you cultivate your own drive.”

She described it as a 6-step process usable in as little as 10 minutes a day. The idea is that before you can lead others authentically, you need a practice for getting clear with yourself about what you actually want and why. “So that when it’s time for you to come out in front of other people and inspire them to certain actions, you have already cultivated that within you.”

–> To learn the whole process of how Victoria developed a clear picture of who she was and what she wanted to achieve, you can find her 6 steps at Strategicmeditation.com.

Now, back to the blog:)

Following Your Method

There is a second, quieter way this gap forms when leaders who’ve built their own methodology and then don’t use it themselves.

“For me, I have the Momentum Strategic Planning Method, and Victoria has Strategic Meditation,” I said. “What we see is that leaders who don’t follow their own method will also create that chasm between who they are in front of people and who they are just hanging out.”

I used the comic book character Two-Face as the extreme version of what happens when that split goes unaddressed. Victoria added the origin of the reference. “That was Harvey, who was Two-Face. And the how he got to that state was through rejecting a part of himself, and it came from his trauma, his unprocessed trauma.”

Authentic leadership is the opposite move. Accepting all aspects of yourself, instead of pretending to be something you aren’t. “Being more congruent and aligned within yourself,” as Victoria put it, “rather than splitting off, in order for me to be acceptable, I have to put on this face for other people.”

Three Things to Do This Week

  • Write down one leadership habit or standard you’ve adopted from someone else (a book, a mentor, a company culture) and ask honestly whether it actually feels like you.

  • Notice one place where you follow advice you give to others, and one place where you don’t. Pick the smaller gap to close first.

  • If you’ve built a career or team you don’t actually like being in charge of, write your own definition of success from scratch, as if starting over today.

What’s Coming Next

Next week’s episode goes further into this same territory, looking into another side of what it means to lead authentically when no one’s watching. Join us Wednesday at 3:30pm ET on LinkedIn Live and YouTube.

If this episode named something you’re experiencing, comment below or send a DM on LinkedIn to Victoria or me with your own definition of success.

READY TO KEEP GROWING?

Explore how to create success systems that honor your unique journey and expertise.

Subscribe to The Weekly Reset, where I share research, ideas, and strategies for leaders navigating the complexities of sustained impact.

Join the Accountability Club — support designed for strategic planning, implementation, and growth with a monthly peer mastermind for meaningful connection and ongoing strategic support.

If you’re looking for a personalized partnership to create space, a plan, and focus in your leadership, let’s talk. I offer Private Executive Coaching for executives and entrepreneurs ready to move from overwhelmed to clear, from scattered to focused.

Send me a message, I’d love to explore how we can support your continued growth.

Do You Feel You Need
Help With Accountability?

Would You Like to Be
the Leader Your Team Needs?

Not sure? Sign up for our FREE, once-a-month
Founder to CEO Workshop on September 13th
and we will identify it together